The limits of nostalgia

In case you haven’t heard, Oasis, the legendary British rock band from the 90s, have reformed. They are currently touring the country in a series of concerts that have attracted millions of fans. Apart from the music, perhaps their biggest appeal is the nostalgia they evoke. They remind people of a time when life seemed simpler and more interesting. It’s intoxicating.

But is nostalgia always a true reflection of how things used to be? Probably not. Nostalgia tends to mythologise the past, making it seem more epic and fulfilling than it was at the time. Nostalgia also tends to airbrush the past, turning it into a glossy version of itself – minus the warts and blemishes.

What has this got to do with the Church? Christians can also succumb to the industry of religious nostalgia. We buy into the belief that anything worth celebrating only happened in the past, that the present is a pale reflection of former spiritual glories. The problem with this is that it creates an escapist mindset, one where we expect little of God today. How should we respond?

First, we should give thanks to God for the past without idolising it. Give credit where credit is due, recognising the faithful acts of God’s people in the past, as well as God’s interventions at critical moments in history: the Reformation; the Great Revival; the Missionary Movement. Acknowledge these movements and give glory to God. But don’t idolise the past as though God’s power is somehow restricted to the past alone. That stifles faith.

Second, we should give thanks for the present without despising it. Yes, today’s world may seem super challenging: rampant unbelief, materialism, and little fear of God. But that doesn’t mean God isn’t at work. Amid the godlessness people are still coming to faith in Jesus. God has put us where we are for ‘such a time as this,’ not ‘such a time as then’ (Esther 4:14) We are called to be missionaries to the twentieth-first century, not the sixteenth.

Finally, look forward to the future with anticipation. Whatever the challenges of the present, one thing’s for sure: Jesus is coming soon! On that day we’ll step into a future in which all spiritual opposition will disappear. Jesus will be crowned Lord of all history; under His reign we will celebrate salvation’s completion (Revelation 1:7,8). So, instead of looking back in anger, look forward in hope.