One of the criticisms often levelled at Christians is that they are too judgemental. When we describe someone as being ‘judgemental’ what we usually mean is that they are harsh and critical of those who do not meet their personal standards. They write them off as failures, unworthy of acceptance. This is a cruel, exclusionary practice. But does Christianity actively encourage it?
When we look at the life of Jesus, we see that Christianity and judgementalism are incompatible. Jesus Himself was critical of the judgemental spirit seen in the Pharisees, the religious leaders of His day. They routinely criticised and condemned those who failed to keep their strict traditions (Matthew 15:1,2). They claimed to speak on behalf of God, but Jesus said they were out of step with God (Matthew 9:13). He also showed us a better way.
During His ministry on earth, Jesus didn’t spend His time seeking out people to condemn. He befriended sinners, working hard to lead them back to God through repentance and faith (Luke 5:32). In doing so He set a pattern for all His followers. When we see someone sin our first instinct should not be to condemn them, but to pray for them (Luke 6:27,28). We should long that they discover the same mercy and acceptance we have found in Christ (Matthew 5:7).
Of course, this doesn’t mean we do not uphold the standards of God. Neither does it mean we call what is evil, good. But it does mean we hold biblical convictions with love, recognising that at the heart of the gospel stands a Saviour who came to rescue us from condemnation, not reinforce us in it (John 1:17).
So, this is the Christian position: judgementalism is about as compatible with the Christian faith as oil is with water. Sadly, we must accept that professing Christians do sometimes fall into judgemental behaviour (Luke 6:37). But that is despite their Christianity, not because of it. In the meantime, those of us who take our faith seriously should strive to be different. We should hold our convictions confidently, humbly, and with compassion. Just like Jesus did.


