Yours sincerely?

In discussions about religious belief, it’s common to hear people say, “it doesn’t matter what you believe, so long as you’re sincere.” Such an attitude is appealing because it seems open minded and generous. I may not share your faith – but if it works for you, that’s okay. Who am I to judge? What shall we say to this?

The first thing to say is that you can be sincerely wrong in what you believe. Hundreds of years ago people believed the world was flat. This belief ran deep within society, but that didn’t make it true. Ferdinand Magellan put paid to that one. So it is with religion: just because people sincerely hold certain beliefs doesn’t automatically make them valid. To deny this isn’t kind; it’s cruel.

It’s also worth pointing out that you can be sincerely deceived in what you believe. In 2 John 1:7 we are warned that many deceivers have gone out into the world. Their mission is to draw people away from the truth, exploiting them for corrupt gain. Once a person comes under their spell, they may sincerely believe they have found the truth. Yet they have in fact been spiritually duped.

This leads to our final point: you can be sincerely lost in what you believe. As a young driver, I once got lost travelling from Oxford to Kent. Trouble was – I didn’t realise I was lost. It was only by the time I reached Birmingham services that reality dawned on me! How many people sincerely believe they have ‘found God’ not realising they are a million miles away from Him?

When it comes to religious convictions, it’s great to be sincere. But sincerity on its own cannot save you. That’s why Peter declares: ‘we did not follow cleverly devised myths when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but we were eyewitnesses of his majesty’ (2 Peter 1:16). He didn’t just want his readers to be sincere; he wanted them to be certain…